mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 1
  • 10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 2
  • 10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 3
  • 10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 4
  • 10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 5

10 Best Healthy Nut Butters | UK Nutritionist Reviewed

Whether you're looking to get in shape or just maintain a healthful lifestyle, a carefully chosen nut butter can really help. Tasty, filling, and satisfying, they can bridge the gap between meals and be added to a wide range of foods and even smoothies! From almond butter made from 100% almonds to organic multi-nut blends flavoured with yummy ingredients like cacao and agave, there's a healthy nut butter to suit everyone. 


In this buying guide, we'll share the tastiest nut butter with the highest protein to buy in the UK from Amazon, Tesco and Asda. Spoons at the ready! Moreover, we have partnered with Nutritionist Tara Corbett for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver the best information to our users.

Last updated 02/02/2025

Quick List - Top Healthy Nut Butter

1

Meridian

Smooth Almond Butter
Smooth Almond Butter

The Purest, Healthiest Choice Made From 100% Almonds

2

Pip & Nut

Coconut Almond Butter
Coconut Almond Butter

A Luxurious Recipe With All-Natural Ingredients

3

Proper Nutty

Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter
Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter

A Tasty Combo of Smooth and Crunchy

4

Biona Organic

Mixed Nut Butter
Mixed Nut Butter

A Nutritious Blend Of Organically-Grown Nuts

5

Nutcessity

'Try Me' PackPack of 5
'Try Me' Pack

Peanut-Free Butter in 5 Exciting Flavours

Tara Corbett
Expert
Nutritionist
Tara Corbett

mybest UK specialist Tara is a nutritionist and energy coach who helps clients lose weight, improve their eating habits, and get their energy back through their nutrition. Tara specialises in helping busy parents specifically improve their eating with ease and without overwhelm, and get back on track so the whole family can benefit.

Tara Corbett's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest Editing Team
Guide
mybest UK
mybest Editing Team

A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.

mybest Editing Team's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

Fact-Checked & Approved by Nutritionist Tara Corbett

Fact-Checked & Approved by Nutritionist Tara Corbett

Tara is a nutritionist and energy coach who helps clients lose weight, improve their eating habits, and get their energy back through their nutrition. Tara specialises in helping busy parents specifically improve their eating with ease and without overwhelm, and get back on track so the whole family can benefit.

How to Choose a Healthy Nut Butter in the UK

Key Points to Consider

  1. Decide Which Nut Butter to Go For Depending on the Health Benefits
  2. Look Out For a Nut Butter With Extra Ingredients
  3. Check the Sugar and Salt Content
  4. Unless It’s Been Sustainably Produced, Avoid Palm Oil 
1

Decide Which Nut Butter to Go For, Depending on the Health Benefits You’re Looking for and the Texture You Like Best

Decide Which Nut Butter to Go For, Depending on the Health Benefits You’re Looking for and the Texture You Like Best

Pick Crunchy Peanut Butter to Increase Your Fibre Intake, or Select a Smooth Spread for Extra Protein

It's worth noting that not all peanut butters are created equally, as the average crunchy peanut butter can contain around a gram more fibre than its smoother counterpart. Eating a diet high in fibre is especially important for a healthy gut, stabilising blood sugars, and can even help with weight loss. Crunchy PB also contains less saturated fat than smooth, which is important if weight loss and overall heart health is a top priority.'


Plus, although peanut butter generally provides a significant amount of protein, the smooth stuff contains slightly more. Smooth PB also has more of the antioxidant vitamin E which helps protect cells and strengthens the immune system. It's more likely palm oil, or another type of oil, will be used in the production of smooth peanut butter, so look out for any additives.


If you love the taste, take a look at some more of our favourite peanut butters!

Try Almond Butter for a Great Balance of Both Monounsaturated and Polyunsaturated Fats

Another very popular type of nut butter, almond butter can be seen as slightly healthier than peanut butter as it has more vitamins, minerals, and fibre, and contains more healthy, monounsaturated fat – and less of the saturated kind.


In fact, almond butter has a great balance of both monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, which help to decrease instances of cardiovascular disease by lowering blood pressure and cholesterol, according to research studies.

If You Prefer a Sweeter Spread, Opt For Creamy Cashew Butter

Rich, creamy, and naturally sweet, cashew butter tastes incredible on toast, apples, in smoothies or just straight out of the jar. You may see it as a more unusual but butter choice but in fact, it actually pairs well with other foods just like peanut butter does, and brings a delicate nuttiness to sweet or savoury meals and snacks.


Cashew butter is nutrient-dense and packed with protein, calcium, iron, vitamin E, riboflavin and healthy fats such as oleic acid. It also helps to regulate blood sugar levels in the body and the monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats help protect your heart.

To Improve Heart Health, Look For a Hazelnut-Based Butter That’s High in Antioxidants

Although hazelnuts contain high amounts of calories, they provide an abundance of nutrients and healthy fats. Rich in vitamin B6, phosphorus, folic acid, zinc and potassium, hazelnuts are bursting with mono and polyunsaturated fats, which helps reduce inflammation in the body.


The high content of antioxidants in hazelnuts protects against oxidative stress and is beneficial for heart health and even to prevent cancer. Hazelnut butter is decidedly healthy, however, some find the taste slightly bitter. Hazelnuts that have been blended with the skins on are higher in fibre but taste more bitter than those without.

2. Try a Nut Butter With Extra Ingredients Like Sea Salt, Agave Syrup or Cacao for Improved Flavour

2. Try a Nut Butter With Extra Ingredients Like Sea Salt, Agave Syrup or Cacao for Improved Flavour
Source:amazon.co.uk

If you're feeling adventurous and want something more exciting, choose nut butter with some additional ingredients like agave syrup or sea salt. Some have a coconut base instead of using palm oil, and others use coconut meat. The addition of seeds, dates, ground coffee, cacao or even apricots creates complex, decadent flavours for a moreish treat that is still very healthful.


Choose nut butters that have been flavoured with natural ingredients and avoid those that contain refined sugars or syrups. Although flavoured varieties can be both delicious and fun, bear in mind that additional ingredients can bump up the calories and the sugar content. 


It's always best to avoid preservatives and additives, so the best options for healthy nut butters are only those with all-natural ingredients and as close to 100% all nuts as possible.

2

Check the Sugar and Salt Content ― Ideally a Jar Should Contain No More Than 1 G of Salt & Less Than 7 G of Sugar per 100 G

Check the Sugar and Salt Content ― Ideally a Jar Should Contain No More Than 1 G of Salt & Less Than 7 G of Sugar per 100 G

It's best to avoid refined sugars or syrups, as they send the sugar content through the roof and consuming too much of them can have a negative impact on your overall health. Agave syrup is a healthier option, but keep your eye on your serving size as added sugar of any kind can still add extra calories.


Like your nut butter with a hint of salt? Be sure to go for products using natural sea salt rather than table salt for more minerals and make sure your jar contains less than 1 g of salt per 100 g to keep things in balance.


Why not take a look at some other healthy snacks available online?

3

To Protect the Planet, Avoid Palm Oil Unless It’s Been Sustainably Produced

To Protect the Planet, Avoid Palm Oil Unless It’s Been Sustainably Produced

Palm oil is a pretty controversial foodstuff, both in terms of the environment and your health. The consumption of palm oil is increasing and in order to accommodate plantations in places such as Malaysia and Indonesia, tropical forests and peatland are being destroyed, which in turn threatens the survival of endangered species such as orangutans.


However, some nut butter brands contain sustainable palm oil, which means the brands must be careful to source certified, sustainable palm oil and to work closely with producers. The jury is still out on whether consuming sustainable palm oil is a good enough alternative, or whether it's best to try and avoid it altogether.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Healthy Nut Butters in the UK

This ranking has been compiled by the writing team at mybest UK via careful evaluation of the points made in the buying guide and thorough research of each product and comparing multiple verified customer reviews across the EC sites used.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Meridian

Smooth Almond Butter

Meridian Smooth Almond Butter 1

The Purest, Healthiest Choice Made From 100% Almonds

2

Pip & Nut

Coconut Almond Butter

Pip & Nut Coconut Almond Butter 1

A Luxurious Recipe With All-Natural Ingredients

3

Proper Nutty

Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter

Proper Nutty Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter 1

A Tasty Combo of Smooth and Crunchy

4

Biona Organic

Mixed Nut Butter

Biona Organic Mixed Nut Butter 1

A Nutritious Blend Of Organically-Grown Nuts

5

Nutcessity

'Try Me' PackPack of 5

Nutcessity 'Try Me' Pack 1

Peanut-Free Butter in 5 Exciting Flavours

6

Meridian

Smooth Cashew Butter

Meridian Smooth Cashew Butter 1

A Smooth, Thick and Creamy Peanut Alternative

7

Biona Organic

Hazelnut Butter

Biona Organic Hazelnut Butter 1

Made From Small Batches of Freshly Roasted, Organic Hazelnuts

8

Bulk

Natural Roasted Peanut Butter

Bulk Natural Roasted Peanut Butter 1

High Protein PB From a Leading Sports Nutrition Brand

9

Zeina

Almond Butter

Zeina Almond Butter 1

Made in the UK by a Family-Owned Brand

10

Whole Earth

Smooth Organic Peanut Butter

Whole Earth Smooth Organic Peanut Butter 1

A Good Source of Fibre and Protein

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Meridian
Smooth Almond Butter

Smooth Almond Butter 1
Source:tesco.com
Reference price
£2.70
Low Mid
Reference price
£2.70
Low Mid

The Purest, Healthiest Choice Made From 100% Almonds

Sometimes clean and simple is all you need, and Meridian's smooth almond butter doesn't disappoint. Made from nothing but 100% almonds, it is high in vitamin E, protein and fibre, making it a good everyday choice and our number one healthy nut butter.


Meridian are a UK company that doesn't fly their ingredients and believe that great taste doesn't have to cost the earth. As a natural, sustainably made nut butter without any nasties, this is one of the best out there! Choose from a smaller jar or a larger 1 kg tub to keep your cupboard stocked and save on packaging while you're at it.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Pip & Nut
Coconut Almond Butter

Coconut Almond Butter 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£14.40
High Mid
Reference price
£14.40
High Mid

A Luxurious Recipe With All-Natural Ingredients

Pip & Nut have really hit the spot with this slightly sweet and salty nut butter that's incredibly moreish. It's made from a palm-oil-free blend of almond and coconut and provides a natural source of vitamin E and magnesium. The large 1 kg tub will last for ages too, especially if you're adding it to a daily smoothie or using it for baking.


Agave syrup and sea salt are also added to the blend, which possibly makes it a teeny bit less versatile as a cooking ingredient. But it's perfect for enriching healthy meals and snacks with a bit of luxury, and it's still one of the healthiest indulgences we can think of!

No.3

Proper Nutty
Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter

Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter 1
Source:tesco.com
Reference price
£2.99
Low Mid

A Tasty Combo of Smooth and Crunchy

We're pretty excited about the Nowt but Nuts Peanut Butter from Proper Nutty, and its smunchy texture. Smunchy – meaning not quite smooth but not quite crunchy – is their ingenious creation and it's just perfect.


Made in a little factory in Huddersfield, Proper Nutty is Yorkshire's first artisan peanut butter, using high-quality peanuts sourced from Argentina. It's nothing but nuts, absolutely delicious, and it comes in a recyclable jar too!

No.4

Biona Organic
Mixed Nut Butter

Reference price
£3.89
Mid

A Nutritious Blend Of Organically-Grown Nuts

The second Biona offering on our list, this mixed nut butter contains peanuts, hazelnuts, cashews, and almonds – with nothing else added. Harnessing the individual characteristics of each type of nut makes for a nice change from the usual jars.


This jar is an excellent source of protein and slightly lighter than peanut butter, plus, the nutritious combination of nuts provides lots of other vitamins and minerals such as manganese and vitamin B6. Sweet as a nut!

No.5

Nutcessity
'Try Me' PackPack of 5

'Try Me' Pack 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
'Try Me' Pack 2
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£24.99
High
Reference price
£24.99
High

Peanut-Free Butter in 5 Exciting Flavours

For those who eat a lot of nut butter as part of their diet and are looking to spice things up a bit with some decadent new flavours, Nutcessity's 'Try Me' Pack has got you sorted. This 5-jar pack features delicious-sounding flavours like Choc Haz Braz, Caromel Cashew and Gingerbread Almond amongst other tempting combos.


Nutcessity specialises in nut butter and these unconventional offerings prove that you can keep things exciting while being healthy. With a coconut oil base, these jars are totally peanut-free which is perfect for those with allergies. Divine!

No.6

Meridian
Smooth Cashew Butter

Reference price
£2.70
Low Mid

A Smooth, Thick and Creamy Peanut Alternative

Meridian truly are nut butter connoisseurs and their smooth cashew butter is totally dreamy. Made from 96% cashews with a dash of sunflower oil, it has a perfectly smooth texture that you're sure to love. 


The nuts are roasted, creating a savoury taste, and the creaminess is divine. Those who avoid peanuts will find this cashew butter a great alternative, and it works well on celery, in smoothies or even as part of a dip or sauce.

No.7

Biona Organic
Hazelnut Butter

Reference price
£5.10
Mid

Made From Small Batches of Freshly Roasted, Organic Hazelnuts

Tired of the classic nut butter options? Then take a peek at this Organic Hazelnut Butter from health food experts, Biona. It's milled from small batches of freshly roasted, organic hazelnuts with no added oils, emulsifiers, salt, or sugar at all.


Great spread on toast or mixed into porridge, it's creamy, smooth and easy to spread! The distinct sweetness of hazelnuts also works well in baking recipes using cacao, so be sure to pair them together for a match made in heaven. 

No.8

Bulk
Natural Roasted Peanut Butter

Natural Roasted Peanut Butter 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£5.99
Mid
Reference price
£5.99
Mid

High Protein PB From a Leading Sports Nutrition Brand

Bulk are known for their expertise in sports nutrition and foods for fitness, including protein powders and vitamins. So it's no surprise their popular and highly rated Natural Roasted Peanut Butter made it into our list.


Made from 100% roasted whole peanuts, it doesn't contain palm oil, salt, or any other additives, making it a healthy and natural choice. High in protein and a source of fibre, this crunchy PB is not only very moreish but it'll give you lots of energy for a workout session as well.

No.9

Zeina
Almond Butter

Almond Butter 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£13.99
High Mid
Reference price
£13.99
High Mid

Made in the UK by a Family-Owned Brand

If you're looking for a large quantity of smooth roasted almond butter, check out this offering from Zeina. Made from 100% nuts, there is no salt, sugar or oil added, making it a very healthy choice indeed.


Zeina are a family-owned, UK-based company founded in 1983 who specialise in nut products such as cashew butter, pistachio butter and nut snack bags. Although one of the healthiest choices on the list, their almond butter can become quite thick and dry, so you'll probably need to mix it well every time it's opened.

No.10

Whole Earth
Smooth Organic Peanut Butter

Smooth Organic Peanut Butter 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£3.00
Low Mid
Reference price
£3.00
Low Mid

A Good Source of Fibre and Protein

We couldn't create a ranking of the best healthy nut butters without including something from Whole Earth, and their smooth organic variety is one of the best out there. Smooth PB isn't always as healthy as crunchier varieties, but this one is made with natural and organic ingredients, making it both nutritious and nom-worthy.


A good source of protein and fibre, it's made from 91% roasted organic peanuts. It does contain palm oil, but the organic sustainable variety, however, it may be best to avoid palm oil altogether if you can. The sprinkle of sea salt adds to the flavour, but it does contain slightly more of it compared to other jars.

Written and researched by Melanie McPhail

Top 5 Healthy Nut Butter

No. 1: MeridianSmooth Almond Butter

No. 2: Pip & NutCoconut Almond Butter

No. 3: Proper NuttyNowt but Nuts Peanut Butter

No. 4: Biona OrganicMixed Nut Butter

No. 5: Nutcessity'Try Me' PackPack of 5

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Vegan Easter Eggs

10 Best

New Arrivals
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.