mybest
Cosmetics and skincare

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Cosmetics and skincare
  3. 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed
  • 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 1
  • 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 2
  • 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 3
  • 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 4
  • 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 5

10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed

It's tricky finding a mascara that lengthens, volumises and defines your lashes while also remaining safe for use around your eyes. Luckily, there's an easy solution to this problem — hypoallergenic mascara. Hypoallergenic mascara is allergy tested and often ophthalmologist-approved to ensure it won't irritate your delicate eye area, making it an essential purchase if you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses.


This buying guide outlines everything you'll need to consider when searching for hypoallergenic mascara. We'll discuss everything from ingredients to water resistance, and we'll walk you through nine of our favourite picks, including brands such as Lancôme, Bell, and Clinique. We've partnered with Makeup Artist Marie Dancer to ensure that our buying guide is as informative as possible.

Last updated 06/02/2023
Marie Dancer
Expert
Makeup Artist
Marie Dancer

As a professional make-up artist of ten years, Marie's job has taken her all over the UK working at top events, on TV shows and making up beautiful brides. For all her clients she loves emphasising their natural beauty by creating a flawless base that still looks like skin.

Marie Dancer's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest Editing Team
Guide
mybest UK
mybest Editing Team

A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.

mybest Editing Team's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

Fact-Checked & Approved by Makeup Artist Marie Dancer

Fact-Checked & Approved by Makeup Artist Marie Dancer

As a professional makeup artist of ten years, Marie's job has taken her all over the UK, working at top events, on TV shows and making up beautiful brides. For all of her clients, she loves emphasising their natural beauty by creating a flawless base that still looks like skin.


Find out more about Marie and what are her favourite makeup products are through her Instagram! She even shares some industry tips on makeup application too. And if you're interested in getting your makeup done by Marie, you can contact her via her email found at the top of her page.

How to Choose a Hypoallergenic Mascara in the UK

Key Points to Consider
  1. Choose an Opthalmologist-Approved Mascara for Improved Comfort
  2. Avoid Fragrances, Fibres and Waterproof Mascaras if You Have Sensitive Eyes
  3. Pick the Right Wand Style for Adding Volume, Length or Definition
1

Pick an Ophthalmologist Tested Mascara to Ensure the Highest Level of Comfort

Pick an Ophthalmologist Tested Mascara to Ensure the Highest Level of Comfort

As an ophthalmologist is essentially an eye doctor, they know all about the ins and outs of eye care. Using a mascara that has been tested by an ophthalmologist will therefore mean that the product is very unlikely to irritate the delicate skin around the eye area


The majority of the mascaras on our top 10 list have been tested and approved by an ophthalmologist, so you can rest assured that you won't end up with sore peepers after applying them to your lashes! This is a great option for contact lens wearers and those that suffer from leaky lids as you can minimise the risk of a reaction.

2

Avoid Fragrances, Fibres and Waterproof Mascaras if You Have Sensitive Eyes

Avoid Fragrances, Fibres and Waterproof Mascaras if You Have Sensitive Eyes

Opt For Fragrance Free Formulas to Prevent Irritation

Fragrance, which is also referred to as parfum on some ingredient lists, shows up in many of the popular mascaras on the market. It's used to mask the slightly unpleasant chemical smell of some formulations. 


Although fragrance makes the olfactory experience of applying your mascara more pleasant, it's an ingredient that can cause redness or swelling, making it a definite no-no for those with sensitive eyes!

Look For Mascaras Coloured Without Synthetic Dyes

Coloured mascaras can include synthetic dyes, which are an added possible irritant. Although it can be fun to mix up your look with a splash of colour, leave this to another area of the face, such as the lips or nails. 


Eyes are extremely delicate so sticking to more standard shades such as black also means your options are less limiting than finding, say, a sensitive purple mascara. Some coloured mascaras use natural dyes, but these are also an added layer, the less ingredients, the better, so if you’re unsure, try it first or speak to the brand expert.

Fibres Add Volume and Length, but Can Flake and Fall Into Your Eyes

A popular trend recently has been the development of mascaras with fibre-infused formulas. These basically coat your natural lashes with physical fibres, adding length to shorter lashes and making them look more voluminous.


Fibre mascaras are removed with warm water, eliminating the need for make-up removers. This not only saves money can be beneficial if you find your eyes become bloodshot or sting when a cleanser is placed near the eyes. 


However, this added ingredient can irritate - in more extreme cases, you might find that the fibres flake and fall into your eyes, making them itchy and sore! Opt for a mascara without fibres if you have super sensitive eyes. Everyone reacts differently, so it comes down to a case-by-case basis to see what works for you.

Stick To a Formula That’s Easy to Remove

You might feel tempted by waterproof or water-resistant mascaras that boast 24 hour wear, but a product with this kind of tough formula is likely to require more intensive cleansing to properly remove it. 


As you can imagine, scrubbing away at your lashes will only lead to irritation, so it's best to avoid long-lasting products if you have sensitive eyes. Instead, go for a gentle formula that's easy to remove - your eyes will thank you!

3

Choose a Thicker Wand With a Precision Tip to Add Volume, or Rectangular Wands for Length and Definition

Choose a Thicker Wand With a Precision Tip to Add Volume, or Rectangular Wands for Length and Definition

Hypoallergenic Mascara wands usually come in one of two varieties - thick wands and rectangular wands - each of which has its own benefits. The right wand style for you will depend on the type of eyelashes you have and the results you're hoping to achieve with your hypoallergenic mascara.


A thicker wand is excellent if you have a full set of lashes, and will allow you to:
  • Easily coat each lash for a volumised, false lash look
  • Build up layers quickly
  • Give a rounded look by reaching into the inner corners with a precision tip

On the other hand, a rectangular brush is an excellent choice if you're looking to:
  • Add length to your lashes by coating each hair and reaching even the shortest lashes
  • Define lashes - skinny, rectangular wands are easier to control
  • Apply mascara to mature or hooded eyes without the fear of transfer or smudging onto your skin
Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras in the UK

This ranking has been compiled by the writing team at mybest UK via careful evaluation of the points made in the buying guide and thorough research of each product and comparing multiple verified customer reviews across the EC sites used.
Popularity
Products
Image
Price
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Bell

HYPOAllergenic Mascara

Bell HYPOAllergenic Mascara 1枚目

£4.38

Low

Cheap and Cheerful, With a Simple Ingredients List

2

Lancôme

Hypnôse Mascara

Lancôme Hypnôse Mascara 1枚目

£27.00

High

Luxury Mascara for Volume and Definition

3

Elizabeth Arden

Grand Entrance Mascara

Elizabeth Arden Grand Entrance Mascara 1枚目

£22.00

High Mid

Curved Brush Provides Plenty of Volume and Curl

4

Eye Care

Volumizing Mascara

Eye Care Volumizing Mascara 1枚目

£17.40

Mid

Specially Formulated for Sensitive Eyes

5

La Roche-Posay

Toleraine Mascara

La Roche-Posay Toleraine Mascara 1枚目

£20.00

High Mid

A Gentle Mascara by a Trusted Skincare Brand

6

Poppy Austin

Argan Oil Natural & Organic Mascara

Poppy Austin Argan Oil Natural & Organic Mascara 1枚目

£12.34

Mid

Nourishing Mascara That’s 100% Vegan

7

Physicians Formula

Killer Curves Mascara

Physicians Formula Killer Curves Mascara 1枚目

£7.54

Low Mid

Ophthalmologist Tested Formula for an Instant Lift

8

No7

Extreme Length Mascara

No7 Extreme Length Mascara 1枚目

£13.00

Mid

Buildable Mascara for Longer Lashes

9

Clinique

Lash Power Mascara

Clinique Lash Power Mascara 1枚目

£21.19

High Mid

Smudge-Free Waterproof Mascara That Won’t Irritate Eyes

10

L’Oreal Paris

Paradise Castor Oil-Enriched Volumising Mascara

L’Oreal Paris Paradise Castor Oil-Enriched Volumising Mascara 1枚目

£7.92

Low Mid

Add Volume While Caring for Your Lashes

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

BellHYPOAllergenic Mascara

HYPOAllergenic Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£4.38
Low
Reference price
£4.38
Low

Cheap and Cheerful, With a Simple Ingredients List

In terms of suitability for sensitive eyes, this mascara ticks every box! The ingredients list is simple, but this product adds an amazing amount of length and volume to your lashes. 


We love the slim brush, which will help you to reach even those tiny hairs in the corners of your eyes. Plus, it carefully separates every lash, adding definition for a bold final look. Budget-friendly, delicate, and smudge-proof - this really is the best hypoallergenic mascara out there!

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

LancômeHypnôse Mascara

Reference price
£27.00
High

Luxury Mascara for Volume and Definition

Hypnôse mascara by Lancôme is iconic - and for a good reason! It's incredibly buildable, which allows you to control how dramatic you want your final look to be. Whether you just want a slight boost to your natural lashes or you're after a striking evening look, the elegant wand will work magic on your eyes!


The unique formula provides intense colour while leaving lashes feeling soft and supple rather than feeling heavy. Although this is one of the pricier products on our list, it's totally worth it if you fancy some luxury!

No.3

Elizabeth ArdenGrand Entrance Mascara

Reference price
£22.00
High Mid

Curved Brush Provides Plenty of Volume and Curl

We recommend Grand Entrance by Elizabeth Arden if you're looking for something that's long-lasting without being waterproof. The formula is water-resistant, so it can tolerate water to a certain extent but can be removed much more quickly than a waterproof product.


Thanks to the delicate curved brush, this mascara instantly provides volume with just one or two coats. We can't think of a better way to add a touch of glamour to your makeup routine!

No.4

Eye CareVolumizing Mascara

Volumizing Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£17.40
Mid
Reference price
£17.40
Mid

Specially Formulated for Sensitive Eyes

Eye Care is known for formulating makeup especially for sensitive eyes, with carefully selected ingredients that won't cause irritation. This is a gentle product that's suitable for even the most delicate peepers.


We love the fact that this formula is enriched with silicium, which strengthens your lashes and helps them to grow longer. While it does have a subtle odour during the application process, you won't notice it at all once it's dried!

No.5

La Roche-PosayToleraine Mascara

Toleraine Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£20.00
High Mid
Reference price
£20.00
High Mid

A Gentle Mascara by a Trusted Skincare Brand

You might already be familiar with La Roche-Posay, a French brand that creates products especially for sensitive skin. The great news is that they also have a makeup line - perfect if you're looking for a mascara that won't irritate sensitive eyes!


This hypoallergenic formula not only adds definition, but it noticeably increases lash length. Best of all, the light, creamy texture of the liquid makes it feel like you're wearing nothing at all!

No.6

Poppy AustinArgan Oil Natural & Organic Mascara

Argan Oil Natural & Organic Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£12.34
Mid
Reference price
£12.34
Mid

Nourishing Mascara That’s 100% Vegan

Poppy Austin is a small UK-based brand dedicated to offering high-quality skincare products that are vegan, cruelty-free and all-natural. True to form, this mascara is palm-oil free, contains organic ingredients, and is 100% vegan.


Its main ingredient is argan oil, a natural ingredient that'll smooth and nourish your lashes as it volumises them. It's also smudge-proof and flake-resistant, making this a great, eco-conscious pick.

No.7

Physicians FormulaKiller Curves Mascara

Killer Curves Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£7.54
Low Mid

Ophthalmologist Tested Formula for an Instant Lift

As the name suggests, this affordable mascara focuses on giving your lashes a noticeable curl. It also creates plenty of definition without requiring too many coats, meaning that one tube will last you a while!


Although it provides your lashes with an instant lift, the formula is quite thick and can be drying if used everyday. It also contains collagen so unfortunately it isn't suitable for vegans.

No.8

No7Extreme Length Mascara

Extreme Length Mascara Image 1
Source:boots.com
Reference price
£13.00
Mid
Reference price
£13.00
Mid

Buildable Mascara for Longer Lashes

This luscious lengthening mascara from No7 coincidentally lands at number 7 on our list! We love its simple ingredients listing, which doesn't overload the delicate eye area with too many irritants. Plus, it's extremely buildable.


However, users either love or hate its brush - while some find it to be ultra-flexible and perfect for reaching lashes in the corners of the eyes, others say that this actually makes it harder to control!

No.9

CliniqueLash Power Mascara

Reference price
£21.19
High Mid

Smudge-Free Waterproof Mascara That Won’t Irritate Eyes

This mascara is one of Clinique's gentler products - it's designed especially for sensitive eyes and ophthalmologist-tested, for your peace of mind.


The staying power of this waterproof product is a definite plus for us, as hypoallergenic formulas are often prone to smudging. However, this also means that it's harder to remove at the end of the day than some of the other options on our list.

No.10

L’Oreal ParisParadise Castor Oil-Enriched Volumising Mascara

Paradise Castor Oil-Enriched Volumising Mascara Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£7.92
Low Mid

Add Volume While Caring for Your Lashes

This dreamy option from L'Oréal will make your lashes appear longer and thicker, thanks to the addition of silky castor oil.


While this product is totally flake-free and ophthalmologist tested, castor oil can sometimes be a mild irritant. So, if you have extremely sensitive eyes or you know that this particular ingredient doesn't agree with your peepers, you may want to give this mascara a miss!

Written and researched by Hannah Kato

Top 5 Hypoallergenic Mascaras

No. 1: BellHYPOAllergenic Mascara

No. 2: LancômeHypnôse Mascara

No. 3: Elizabeth ArdenGrand Entrance Mascara

No. 4: Eye CareVolumizing Mascara

No. 5: La Roche-PosayToleraine Mascara

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Cosmetics and skincare
  3. 10 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed
mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.