mybest
Cosmetics and skincare

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Cosmetics and skincare
  3. 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed
  • 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 1
  • 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 2
  • 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 3
  • 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 4
  • 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed 5

10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed

To make a statement with your eyes that's more pigmented and precise than regular eyeshadow, try a coloured eyeliner pencil or liquid. Owing to the popularity of this bright and bold beauty trend, there are some expert brands out there offering gorgeous felt-tip liners, gel-like precision wands, smudge-proof colours and even water-resistant formulas. Whether you've got blue eyes, brown eyes, or green, there's the perfect colour out there for you!


Our article will help you sort your NYX from your Rimmel and your Barry M from your Urban Decay, ranking and reviewing the best-selling coloured eyeliners you can buy online in the UK from Boots, Amazon and more. Whether you're experimenting with coloured eyeliner sets for detailed makeup looks, you only shop cruelty-free, or you want magnetic, individual colours, you are sure to find one here that makes your eyes pop. Moreover, we have partnered with Makeup Artist Marie Dancer for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver the best information.

Last updated 07/02/2023
Marie Dancer
Expert
Makeup Artist
Marie Dancer

As a professional make-up artist of ten years, Marie's job has taken her all over the UK working at top events, on TV shows and making up beautiful brides. For all her clients she loves emphasising their natural beauty by creating a flawless base that still looks like skin.

Marie Dancer's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest Editing Team
Guide
mybest UK
mybest Editing Team

A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.

mybest Editing Team's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

Fact-Checked & Approved by Makeup Artist Marie Dancer

Fact-Checked & Approved by Makeup Artist Marie Dancer

As a professional makeup artist of ten years, Marie's job has taken her all over the UK, working at top events, on TV shows and making up beautiful brides. For all of her clients, she loves emphasising their natural beauty by creating a flawless base that still looks like skin.


Find out more about Marie and what are her favourite makeup products are through her Instagram! She even shares some industry tips on makeup application too. And if you're interested in getting your makeup done by Marie, you can contact her via her email found at the top of her page.

How to Choose a Coloured Eyeliner in the UK

Key Points to Consider
  1. Choose either a Pencil or Liquid Liner Based on Your Budget and Look
  2. Opt For a Formula That Matches Your Needs: Durability, Smudgability or Precision
  3. Decide Between a Dramatic or a Subtle Range of Colours
1

Choose Between Pencil and Liquid Liners Based on Budget, Makeup Skills and Desired Effects

Choose Between Pencil and Liquid Liners Based on Budget, Makeup Skills and Desired Effects

Pick Eye Pencils if You Want a Low-Effort and Affordable Solution That’s Perfect for Blending

Pencil and liquid liners will both accentuate the eyes whilst offering different looks. Pencils glide into your waterline seamlessly whilst liquids create bold lines on your lid. Each has a place in your make-up bag, so let’s talk about their benefits. For a cheap option that looks great but won't destroy your budget, a pencil should be your first port of call – many cost as little as £2, £3 or £4. 


Less precious with no chance of leakage, they are also great for shoving in your pocket for emergency touch-ups. Since gripping one is second nature, these little tools are easy to manoeuvre and can create dramatic or smudgy lines depending on whether they're blunt or freshly sharpened. 


The soft, creamy tip of an eyeliner pencil also allows easy colour blending. Unlike liquid eyeliner, pencils won't dry out if you forget to put the lid on. They are also much lower maintenance; a single sweep across each lid, and you're good to go. Many are made with long-wear formulas that are creamy enough to blend in a 30-second window but then refuse to budge. 

Go for Liquid Liners to Create Intense Colour, Detailed Looks and Hours of Wear

Coloured liquid eyeliners are fantastic for achieving more complicated or detailed makeup looks, such as a TikTok-worthy transformation or a classic cat-eye flick in vibrant colour. They require a steady hand, though, and achieving a flawless makeup look can be stressful if you're not an expert. Liquid liners don't offer the option of blending, which could be a drawback. 


However, what we love about liquids is the high pigment and intensity of colour you can achieve compared to even the sharpest pencil. Liquid liners often have a limited colour choice, as most often they come in black or brown. If you're experienced using a liquid, transitioning to a pop of colour will be easy.


If you haven't had much practice it can be fiddly and take time to perfect, as mistakes can be obvious. The formulas also often contain silicones or acrylates, making them more adhesive and thus longer-lasting. For a clean, defined liner flick or detailed decoration, it has to be liquid.


If you're after even more of an intense look, pair your liner with a bold eyeshadow pallet!

Use Felt-Tip Pen Eyeliners for More Stability, Bold Colours and Sharp, Precise Lines

If you love the striking colour of a liquid liner but don't feel confident controlling a wand, a pen may be the solution. Wielded like a felt tip, they allow more stability as you draw your seductive cat-eye flick or pretty patterns. These handy products are filled with liquid eyeliner in bold colours that stay put even during humid weather or exercise. 


On the downside, much like regular liquid eyeliners, pens can dry out quickly if not properly cared for and stored. They also have an extremely fine tip which takes a special knack to get right, but once you've cracked it, your coloured liner will be sharp, precise and, frankly, stunning.


To keep your felt tip fresh and ready to go, store it upside down in your brush pot or on your make-up table. This will ensure that the tip is pre-saturated and elongate the life cycle of your make-up. 

2

Select a Formula Based on Whether You Want Something Long-Lasting, Smudgable, or for Detailed Precision

Select a Formula Based on Whether You Want Something Long-Lasting, Smudgable, or for Detailed Precision

Opt For a Smudge and Water-Proof Liner for a Long-Lasting Effect That’s Tough to Remove

Many liners on our list are smudge- and touch-proof, while other formulas go a step further and promise not to budge even underwater, ensuring your liner stays perfect for up to 10 hours. Think about what occasion you're going to be wearing a colourful liner. This will determine whether you go for a subtle, daytime smudgy formula, or a long-wearing, dramatic 24 hr party eye.


Each type of liner has offerings for waterproof, long-wear or shimmer, so once you've decided on your applicator type you can narrow down your search. Eyeliners that are billed as 'smudge-', 'touch-' or 'transfer-proof' will usually contain silicone resin or natural clay derivatives in order to stay put against skin for longer


They can be removed using a sponge or flannel with warm water or your regular cleanser. Waterproof liners contain silicone- or acrylate-based polymers. This enables them to fuse more reliably to the skin without irritation. The molecular structure of these adhesive formulas makes it nearly impossible for water to break the connection to skin without the use of oil, so you'll need to use an oil-based cleanser to remove it.


Add a bit of colour to your cheeks with a nice new bronzer!

Select Smudgable Eyeliners to Create Blended Colours That Are Easy to Remove

Some eyeliners are deliberately billed as smudgeable, perfect for any makeup lover who wants a sexy, carefree effect or who loves to build colours together. This type of liner will have a softer, creamier formula, though it isn't as fade-resistant or long-lasting as a waterproof product.


Coloured eyeliners intended for smudging still have decent staying power, though. You may need more regular touch-ups, but at least you can comfortably take them off without shelling out for a fancy remover. Not ideal for detailed work, but more effective when your aim is an explosion of blended colour.

Consider Fine-Tipped Eyeliners if You’re After Maximum Precision to Create Detailed Looks

Several of the products we've selected have the beauty goal of sharp, precise lines. This is either achieved using an exquisitely fine-tipped brush or a pencil that has an especially tiny diameter, so the surface area coloured is small, even when it's becoming blunt. Coloured eyeliners that have precision as their priority are the best pick if you are aiming to achieve a supremely detailed effect.


Of course, for a look that will have Val Garland yelling 'Ding Dong Darling!', you'll need to bring your confidence and control to achieve a seriously precise flick of eyeliner, but check our spec tables for products aimed at finesse and precision for the most suitable tools for the task.

3

Decide on the Right Range of Colours Depending on Whether You Want a Dramatic or Subtle Look

Decide on the Right Range of Colours Depending on Whether You Want a Dramatic or Subtle Look

Choose Subtle Complimentary Colours for a Low-Key Look, or Go For Vibrant Colours to Create a Statement

If you are going big and plan to achieve a makeup look worthy of the stage, screen or pages of Vogue, look for exciting, vibrant colours that ooze wow-factor like pinks, purples, emeralds and oranges. 


Anyone seeking a more low-key look should opt for natural-toned shades. These could be closer to skin tones, like gold and bronze, or able to enhance the eyes; think classic blues, browns and greens. Shopping for an eyeliner set will, of course, increase your colour options, so if you love a range of choices, select a multipack or palette.

Go For Glitter Eyeliner to Add a Pop of Wow That’s Perfect for a Party

Hoping to bring the party and make sure your eyes shine without swamping your whole lid in flakes of glitter? A sparkly coloured eyeliner couldn't be more fitting. Create a striking, sharp line of glitter along your lash line for a disco makeup look that's never O.T.T. 


These products are also fabulous for adding glam details to creative makeup looks! Remember to treat glitter eyeliners carefully as they need to be tightly fastened to avoid drying out. A drop or two of saline solution can soften and loosen older glitters without damaging the delicate eye area. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Coloured Eyeliners in the UK

mybest UK product recommendations are reviewed and curated by our writers in-house. We focus on in-depth research and analysis of product reviews to carefully select the best products available for the best prices.
Popularity
Products
Image
Price
Click to purchase
Key features
1

NYX

Vivid Brights Eyeliner

NYX Vivid Brights Eyeliner  1枚目

£10.00

Mid

Vibrant and Smudge-Proof Felt-Tip Liner With a Super-Sharp Wand

2

Barry M

Hi Vis Liquid Eyeliner

Barry M Hi Vis Liquid Eyeliner 1枚目

£5.00

Low Mid

A Super-Bold Smudgeproof and Waterproof Hi Vis Liner for a Dramatic Look

3

OPV

Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner

OPV Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner 1枚目

£10.00

Mid

Fun, High-Quality Glitter Liner for Precision, Glitz and Glamour

4

Rimmel

Wonder Swipe 2-in-1

Rimmel Wonder Swipe 2-in-1 1枚目

£4.19

Low Mid

Best Affordable Pink Liquid Eyeliner That’s Smudge-Proof and Stays in Place for 6 Hours

5

Nuonove

Matte Liquid Eyeliner

Nuonove Matte Liquid Eyeliner 1枚目

£18.99

High Mid

The Ultimate Collection of Colourful Matte Liner Pens to Create Unique, Artistic Looks

6

Charlotte Tilbury

Eye Colour Magic Liner Duo

Charlotte Tilbury Eye Colour Magic Liner Duo 1枚目

£21.00

High Mid

2-In-1 Eyeliner Pencils That Are Ideal for Colour Blending When Time Is Short

7

NARS

High-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner

NARS High-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner 1枚目

£19.00

High Mid

High-Pigment Precision Gel Liner Pencil Available in Muted Tones

8

3INA

The Color Pen Eyeliner

3INA  The Color Pen Eyeliner  1枚目

£11.33

Mid

Easy-To-Use Super-Fine Eyeliner Pens With a 14-Hour Wear, Available in 8 Bold Colours

9

Urban Decay

24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil 1枚目

£15.00

High Mid

Creamy and Smudgable Pencil Eyeliners With a Velvet Texture and an 8 Hour Wear Time

10

Barry M

Kohl Eye Pencil

Barry M Kohl Eye Pencil 1枚目

£2.99

Low

Sexy, Glide-on Coloured Pencil Liners, Best for Smudging and Blending

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

NYXVivid Brights Eyeliner

Vivid Brights Eyeliner  Image 1
Source:lookfantastic.com
Reference price
£10.00
Mid
Reference price
£10.00
Mid

Vibrant and Smudge-Proof Felt-Tip Liner With a Super-Sharp Wand

We think the best overall coloured eyeliners come from the NYX Vivid Brights range. There are seven shades, including pink, lilac, green, yellow and blue. The silky-smooth formula glides onto skin like a dream; it's looser and more liquid than the colour from a felt-tip style liner. 


This colour has an oozy, shiny appearance, but its lightly silicone-based formula, though kind to skin, sticks firmly in place through dancing, movement, humidity and rain. The wand also has a slightly angled tip which allows extreme precision. NYX's liners are so fun and easy to use they couldn't fail to sit at number one!

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Barry MHi Vis Liquid Eyeliner

Hi Vis Liquid Eyeliner Image 1
Source:boots.com
Reference price
£5.00
Low Mid
Reference price
£5.00
Low Mid

A Super-Bold Smudgeproof and Waterproof Hi Vis Liner for a Dramatic Look

The reasons we've ranked this product so highly are many in number. This liquid colour is super bold, strong and bright. Both smudge-proof and waterproof, it gives your eyes a high-drama, almost neon glow that adds a funky flash of colour to any makeup look. 


We love how easy it is to use, making it accessible for beginners who want to experiment with colour but don't feel confident achieving precision. Choose from vibrant blue, zingy chartreuse yellow-green, pink and lilac. Barry M is vegan and cruelty-free, which is a final bonus!

No.3

OPVGive Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner

Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner Image 1
Source:asos.com
Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner Image 2
Source:asos.com
Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner Image 3
Source:asos.com
Give Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner Image 4
Source:asos.com
Reference price
£10.00
Mid
Reference price
£10.00
Mid

Fun, High-Quality Glitter Liner for Precision, Glitz and Glamour

This has to be the best glitter liner you can find online regarding price, quality, effect and lasting time. It's water-based, which helps you avoid the clogging and clumping that you risk with a glittery eyeliner – just right for adding a flicker of subtle glitz to colourful makeup. 


The exquisitely fine brush tip on the wand is another big perk since it means a brief swipe can still be precise. Reviewers say it has a mildly adhesive quality that won't budge easily. You can achieve a smooth, professional final look in moments, and we love the funky range of shades, including two blues, purple, gold, and bronze. 

No.4

RimmelWonder Swipe 2-in-1

Wonder Swipe 2-in-1 Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£4.19
Low Mid

Best Affordable Pink Liquid Eyeliner That’s Smudge-Proof and Stays in Place for 6 Hours

Considering the super affordable price tag, this liner is really effective and well-loved by consumers and influencers alike. It doesn't bleed or smudge, and although it takes a little knack to control the wand, it is overall pretty user-friendly and stays in place for 6 hours


We particularly love this pink, which can sometimes be unflattering if the shade is too sickly. Otherwise, Wonder Swipe comes in a joyful range of 16 colours, including purples, greens, blues, silver, yellow and gold. It truly does rival more expensive products at a fraction of the cost. 

No.5

NuonoveMatte Liquid Eyeliner

Matte Liquid Eyeliner Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£18.99
High Mid
Reference price
£18.99
High Mid

The Ultimate Collection of Colourful Matte Liner Pens to Create Unique, Artistic Looks

We reckon this has to be the brightest range of coloured eyeliners you can find online today for such a cheap price. They have bags of effusive customer reviews, and the twelve fantastic colours will allow you to create unique combinations and detailed artistic looks. 


The matte-effect felt pens create an almost photoshopped effect on the face; it's like you're colouring over your face with bright lines that leap straight from your skin. The extra-fine tip allows extreme control and makes flawless makeup easy, even for beginners. 

No.6

Charlotte TilburyEye Colour Magic Liner Duo

Reference price
£21.00
High Mid

2-In-1 Eyeliner Pencils That Are Ideal for Colour Blending When Time Is Short

Get 16 hours' worth of delectable colour with these carefully paired dual-tipped liners. While they sit at the more costly end of the price bracket, these 2-in-1 pencils not only save you decision-making time but also allow you to create a coherent makeup look with just one product.


Charlotte Tilbury products are always vegan and cruelty-free, so this pretty eyeliner is a great ethical choice. The totally blendable colours come in shades of golden bronze, deep and bright green, complementary shades of ocean and sky blue and a maroon/pink blend. 

No.7

NARSHigh-Pigment Longwear Eyeliner

Reference price
£19.00
High Mid

High-Pigment Precision Gel Liner Pencil Available in Muted Tones

A high-pigment, precision pencil from one of makeup's best-loved brands, this is a super pick for anyone who loves the ease and creaminess of a pencil with a dense, beautiful brightness that's almost as rich as a liquid colour. You're promised twelve hours, and reviewers seem to agree it lasts well without the need for touch-ups. 


This is another coloured eyeliner that you can blend effectively before it sets in place, so you get the effect of a softer, creamier pencil at first and then a lasting effect that can withstand sweat, humidity and plenty of movement. It comes in a superb, subtle range of colours, so if you're looking for something more striking, perhaps another one is best.

No.8

3INA The Color Pen Eyeliner

The Color Pen Eyeliner  Image 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£11.33
Mid
Reference price
£11.33
Mid

Easy-To-Use Super-Fine Eyeliner Pens With a 14-Hour Wear, Available in 8 Bold Colours

Orange eyeliner looks truly delectable on all skin colours, from deep, blue-toned black skin to chocolate and olive tones to porcelain white – and this is our favourite on the market today. Whether you're a seasoned MUA or a complete beginner, using this pen is easy as pie, and multiple reviewers confirm the 14-hour-wear promise.


3ina have perfected a gorgeous eyeliner with a super-fine felt tip ideal for precision and lots of highly pigmented colour. The product comes in eight bold shades from blues and lilacs through a mossy green to yellow, pink and white - perfect for party looks and makeup statements, but not the best for subtlety!

No.9

Urban Decay24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Reference price
£15.00
High Mid

Creamy and Smudgable Pencil Eyeliners With a Velvet Texture and an 8 Hour Wear Time

We can't get enough of this dreamy pencil liner from Urban Decay. Get the best of both worlds with the creamy, smudgeable texture that blends brilliantly with other shades in a 30-second window. After that, the highly pigmented waxy formula sets and refuses to budge for a good 6 to 8 hours. 


While the pencil diameter isn't as slim as some other precision eyeliners we've chosen, the sumptuous colours are edgy and artful. Think sweet and sludgy greens, deep wines and spangled silver.

No.10

Barry MKohl Eye Pencil

Reference price
£2.99
Low

Sexy, Glide-on Coloured Pencil Liners, Best for Smudging and Blending

For those among us who like a roughed-up rock-and-roll eye and love a bargain, Barry M's super-smudgeable coloured eyeliner is just the job. This is a pencil liner, so it's not only affordable but also extra easy to use. Keep it sharp for detail and medium-blunt for softer lines. 


Barry M is a completely vegan and cruelty-free makeup range, and their coloured kohl eye pencils are available in six shades including bright blues, deep pinks and sultry bronze. This product is not designed for precision and may not last through hours of wear, but it's cheap, cheerful and offers gorgeous colour.

Written and researched by Annie Hopkins

Top 5 Coloured Eyeliners

No. 1: NYXVivid Brights Eyeliner

No. 2: Barry MHi Vis Liquid Eyeliner

No. 3: OPVGive Me Glow Metal and Liquid Glitter Liner

No. 4: RimmelWonder Swipe 2-in-1

No. 5: NuonoveMatte Liquid Eyeliner

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Cosmetics and skincare
  3. 10 Best Coloured Eyeliners 2023 | UK Makeup Artist Reviewed
mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.