mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
  • 5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 1
  • 5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 2
  • 5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 3
  • 5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 4
  • 5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed 5

5 Best Mince Pies | UK Nutritionist Reviewed

Christmas just isn't Christmas without a proper mince pie, but picking ones with mincemeat worthy of Mary Berry on top of pastry Paul Hollywood would be proud of is easier said than done. In this article, we're here to make sure your festive spread is complete by ranking the top 5 best mince pies in the UK! With a delicious range on offer, this article certainly got our mouths watering and you won't be disappointed with our favourites. 


From bakeries working with traditional methods to those that like to spice things up a little we have something to suit all tastes. Now all you need to do is stock up on the brandy butter, snuggle up and indulge in this favourite of Christmas treats. Moreover, we have partnered with Nutritionist Tara Corbett for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver the best information to our users.

Last updated 02/02/2025

Quick List - Top Mince Pies

1

Walkers

Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts
Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts

Scottish Shortbread Pies with Lashings of Gin Soaked Fruit, Pack of 6

2

Harrods

Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince PiesPack of 6
Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince Pies

Pack of Six Luxurious Mince Pies Flavoured with Chocolate, Cherry and Clementine

3

Country Farm Cakes

Traditional Mince Pies
Traditional Mince Pies

12 Traditional Mince Pies That Taste Like Home Baking

4

Grandma Wild

Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies
Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies

Pack of 6 Mince Pies Topped with Rich Brandy for an Extra Kick

5

Hamper House

Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper
Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper

Brandy Butter Mince Pies in the Perfect Christmas Gift Hamper

Tara Corbett
Expert
Nutritionist
Tara Corbett

mybest UK specialist Tara is a nutritionist and energy coach who helps clients lose weight, improve their eating habits, and get their energy back through their nutrition. Tara specialises in helping busy parents specifically improve their eating with ease and without overwhelm, and get back on track so the whole family can benefit.

Tara Corbett's Profile
…Continue reading
mybest Editing Team
Guide
mybest UK
mybest Editing Team

A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.

mybest Editing Team's Profile
…Continue reading
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.

Table of Contents

Fact-Checked & Approved by Nutritionist Tara Corbett

Fact-Checked & Approved by Nutritionist Tara Corbett

Tara is a nutritionist and energy coach who helps clients lose weight, improve their eating habits, and get their energy back through their nutrition. Tara specialises in helping busy parents specifically improve their eating with ease and without overwhelm, and get back on track so the whole family can benefit.

How to Choose Mince Pies in the UK

Key Points to Consider
  1. Consider What Kinds of Fruits and Spices Are Present in the Recipe
  2. Look for Large Packs of Pies if you are Expecting Guests
  3. Gluten and Dairy Free Options are Best if you are Catering for Intolerances or Allergies
1

Go for Classic Fruit Like Raisins and Currants for the Original Taste or Add in Complex Flavours From Spices Like Stem Ginger and Fennel Seeds

Go for Classic Fruit Like Raisins and Currants for the Original Taste or Add in Complex Flavours From Spices Like Stem Ginger and Fennel Seeds

A standard mince pie will contain mincemeat made from raisins, sultanas and currants, often with the addition of apple for a sweet, tangy base. For a slight variation on the traditional flavour, opt for mince pies containing cherries, which give a sour-sharp kick, or apricots which smooth out the tart mincemeat flavour with sweetness. 


When it comes to spices, a catch-all title of 'mixed spice' can often be spotted on ingredients list. This will usually incorporate some combination of the following roots and plants; cinnamon, coriander, caraway, nutmeg, ginger, cloves and mace. For a more nuanced flavour, consider mince pies containing real stem ginger, cassia, fennel seeds or even turmeric.

2

Choose Multi-Packs of 12 for Larger Guestlists to Nibble On

Choose Multi-Packs of 12 for Larger Guestlists to Nibble On

Another factor to consider is the number of pies you get per pack. Most of these cute Christmas nibbles come in packs of six, which makes for one each for medium sized families, or provides a couple of leftovers on Boxing Day for parents with two kids. Boxes of four suit small families well, though you'll need double up if you have a longer guest list - which won't be the best value for money.


If you love the idea of a large platter covered in hot mince pies, we suggest choosing a twelve pack. The pies themselves may be a little smaller, but they are great value if you're on a tight budget and ensure everyone gets at least one pie. They even present the possibility of yummy leftovers to heat up on New Year's Eve!

3

If You Have Any Dietary Requirements, Opt for Gluten-Free and Vegan Options

If You Have Any Dietary Requirements, Opt for Gluten-Free and Vegan Options

The idea of a gluten-free mince pie might sound unappealing to some, but if wheat and other gluten products mess up your digestion, you'll be relieved to know there are some smashing products on the market, often made with potato or maize starch.


Vegan alternatives are also getting better these days, so it's never been easier to find a fully plant-based mince pie to sink your teeth into. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

5 Best Mince Pies in the UK

This ranking has been compiled by the writing team at mybest UK via careful evaluation of the points made in the buying guide and thorough research of each product and comparing multiple verified customer reviews across the EC sites used.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Walkers

Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts

Walkers Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts 1

Scottish Shortbread Pies with Lashings of Gin Soaked Fruit, Pack of 6

2

Harrods

Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince PiesPack of 6

Harrods Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince Pies 1

Pack of Six Luxurious Mince Pies Flavoured with Chocolate, Cherry and Clementine

3

Country Farm Cakes

Traditional Mince Pies

Country Farm Cakes Traditional Mince Pies 1

12 Traditional Mince Pies That Taste Like Home Baking

4

Grandma Wild

Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies

Grandma Wild Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies 1

Pack of 6 Mince Pies Topped with Rich Brandy for an Extra Kick

5

Hamper House

Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper

Hamper House Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper 1

Brandy Butter Mince Pies in the Perfect Christmas Gift Hamper

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Walkers
Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts

Shortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£4.99
Low Mid
Reference price
£4.99
Low Mid

Scottish Shortbread Pies with Lashings of Gin Soaked Fruit, Pack of 6

The standout feature of these mince pies is that the mind-blowing mincemeat is infused with gin, a quirky twist on more typical boozy festive flavours. Made by the world renowned Walkers of Scotland, the cases are made from buttery, melt-in-the-mouth shortbread with a crumb topping.


Alongside the traditional fruits found in a mince pie, Walkers have added a zesty citrus extra, to really tie the flavour of the gin. These top ranking mince pies are made here in the UK, so the local economy will thank you just as heartily as your taste buds will! 

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Harrods
Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince PiesPack of 6

Chocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince Pies 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£22.00
High Mid
Reference price
£22.00
High Mid

Pack of Six Luxurious Mince Pies Flavoured with Chocolate, Cherry and Clementine

We wouldn't expect anything less from Harrods and these mince pies certainly do not disappoint. Baked by a family run bakery in the Highlands and then sent to Knightsbridge these are about as decedent as you can get. Mouth watering pastry filled with a less traditional mixture of chocolate, cherries and clementine. 


With a gold dusting, you might expect, this pack of six does not come cheap, certainly not suitable for those trying to concur Christmas on a tight budget. If you fancy a splurge though, and a break away from traditional mincemeat, you definitely can't go wrong with these.

No.3

Country Farm Cakes
Traditional Mince Pies

Traditional Mince Pies 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£11.50
Mid
Reference price
£11.50
Mid

12 Traditional Mince Pies That Taste Like Home Baking

If you want to greet your guests with homemade mince pies but don't have the time, or inclination, to bake yourself, then this is the option for you. These mince pies from Country Farm Cakes are traditionally handmade, so really have the taste of home cooking. 


Unlike others on our list, these mince pies still include the tried and tested fruits and spices to create that heart warming taste synonymous with Christmas. These are definitely up there price wise, but you are getting 12 for the cost and given how delicious they are we think that it's great value for money

No.4

Grandma Wild
Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies

Luxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£4.95
Low Mid
Reference price
£4.95
Low Mid

Pack of 6 Mince Pies Topped with Rich Brandy for an Extra Kick

As these are from an independent producer, they give little away about saturated fat and sugar content, but what we can say is that these are worth indulging in. The pastry is flaky and the mincemeat follows traditional recipes to bring a rich flavour to the table. 


For an extra indulgence Grandma Wild has packed each mince pie with a brandy punch for good measure, so be aware they are not suitable for children. A pack of six is very reasonable priced, we say stock up while you can!

No.5

Hamper House
Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper

Christmas Gourmet Food Hamper 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£34.99
High Mid
Reference price
£34.99
High Mid

Brandy Butter Mince Pies in the Perfect Christmas Gift Hamper

In our opinion, nothing goes better with mince pies than brandy butter, and so these mince pies, with brandy butter mixed in at the baking stage, are perfection. Alongside the traditionally mixed filling these boast delicious, hand made pastry.


These pies may come as part of a gift set, and therefore are definitely the priciest on our list, but we think they are worth spending on. With other delicious treats on offer in this set including sticky toffee and Christmas jam, you can't go wrong if sending this hamper as a gift for someone special. 

Written and researched by Annie Hopkins

Top 5 Mince Pies

No. 1: WalkersShortbread Miniature Gin Infused Fruit Tarts

No. 2: HarrodsChocolate, Cherry & Clementine Christmas Mince PiesPack of 6

No. 3: Country Farm CakesTraditional Mince Pies

No. 4: Grandma WildLuxury Deep Brandy Mince Pies

No. 5: Hamper HouseChristmas Gourmet Food Hamper

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Cake Mixes

9 Best

New Arrivals
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.