mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
mybest
Food cupboardHelping You Find the Best
  • 10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More 1
  • 10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More 2
  • 10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More 3
  • 10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More 4
  • 10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More 5

10 Best Gherkins UK | Mrs Elswood Maille and More

Oh, gherkins. Those delicious cucumbers pickled in vinegar. They come by the jar, in all shapes and sizes from extra-large dill pickles to crinkle-cut rounds, gourmet gherkin ribbons to mini cocktail gherkins (cornichons if you're fancy!). These tangy, crunchy, healthy treats, known in the East End of London as wallies, are low in calories and high in beneficial potassium, vitamin A and beta-carotene. 


Supermarkets like Asda, Tesco and even Amazon have terrific options, so whether you're trying a recipe with gherkins, garnishing a BBQ burger or making a sandwich, there are plenty of choices. Our article will help you compare the top-rated, best-selling products in the UK. Here's to the savoury staples that are tasty and good for you. Ready? Steady? Gherkin!

Last updated 02/02/2025

Quick List - Top Gherkins

1

Garner's

Gin Pickled Gherkins
 Gin Pickled Gherkins

Lusciously Gin-Infused for a Taste of Luxury

2

Vadasz

Fresh Garlic and Dill Pickles
Fresh Garlic and Dill Pickles

Gorgeously Gourmet Garlic and Dill Ribbons

3

Maille

French Extra Fine Cornichons Pack of 2
French Extra Fine Cornichons

Fine, French-Style Cornichons for Meat and Cheese

4

Waitrose

Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins
Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins

Popular Cocktail Gherkins With Lots of Bite

5

Mrs Elswood

Sweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices
Sweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices

Just Right for Packed Lunches

mybest Editing Team
Guide
mybest UK
mybest Editing Team

A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.

mybest Editing Team's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

How to Choose Gherkins in the UK - Buying Guide

There are some truly yummy gherkins out there at the best supermarkets, some of which have intriguing or unusual flavours but all of which make a yummy snack, side or salad addition. Let's think about the small variations that may sway you towards a particular jar of gherkins!

1

Slices, Ribbons or Cornichons? Choose Depending on Your Snacking Plans

Slices, Ribbons or Cornichons? Choose Depending on Your Snacking Plans

Gherkins come in all shapes and sizes, each of which is suited to a slightly different snacking style. If you're looking to add moisture and tang to a burger, round slices are the most traditional, with their crinkled cousins said to be more flavoursome owing to their larger surface area. Pop one or two on top of your beef or veggie patty for that classic burger-joint flavour combo. 


Long, thin slices of cucumber work well in sandwiches, serving the same purpose as they do in a burger but fitting better with sliced bread. For a salad with a salty freshness, consider throwing in some gherkin ribbons. To add European class to a cheese board or pre-dinner nibbles, choose mini cocktail gherkins, also known as cornichons, which have a satisfying, juicy bite.

2

Select Gherkins Pickled in a Base That Appeals to Your Tastes

Select Gherkins Pickled in a Base That Appeals to Your Tastes

Most jars of gherkins use spirit vinegar to pickle their cucumbers. Spirit vinegar is made from molasses sugar, using a double fermentation process where the sugar is converted into alcohol and the alcohol into acetic acid. This makes up only a small percentage of the finished vinegar, but it's what gives it that signature acidic twang.


For a more sophisticated gherkin, consider pickles in a vinegar with an extra-complex taste, such as white wine vinegar, which is sweet, fruity and mild thanks to the wine grapes used in its production. Barley malt vinegar is also flavourful, with a nutty, citrusy, caramel-laced flavour not dissimilar to the taste of a malted ale. 


In contrast, distilled white vinegar (the kind you could use for household cleaning) has a much stronger and more acidic effect on your tastebuds. It will generally be more affordable and gherkins pickled in it still taste great, it's just very striking and pungent. Look out for gherkins pickled in spirits like gin for an alcoholic kick; a great gift for fans of the botanical booze. 

3

Select Gherkins Flavoured With Added Ingredients for a More Vibrant Taste

Select Gherkins Flavoured With Added Ingredients for a More Vibrant Taste

The majority of jarred gherkins contain cucumbers pickled along with a variety of other flavours. This can really alter the taste sensation, so be aware of the key tasting notes that come in each jar! The most common option is mustard seeds, which add a lovely textured crunch as well as the tartness only mustard can achieve. 


Dill, a feathery herb with a fresh, citrus taste, offsets the tartness of the vinegar beautifully. You may also find onion, which offers a tangy sweetness. Then there's whole hot peppers for a fiery kick, or mixed spices for a more subtle heat. Any combination of tarragon, coriander, fennel, turmeric and caraway seeds can add even more depth of flavour.


If you spot 'natural flavourings' on an ingredients list in the UK, the contents may sound vague but will have been regulated by the Food Standards Agency. However, go for gherkins with recognisable ingredients to guarantee the most complex flavours.

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Gherkins in the UK

Right, now you've got an idea of what our supermarkets have to offer, let's take a look at the ten best jars of gherkins in the UK. Add some moisture and tang to burgers and sandwiches, spruce up a salad or simply tuck in with a fork. Here we gherkin!
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Key features
1

Garner's

Gin Pickled Gherkins

Garner's  Gin Pickled Gherkins 1

Lusciously Gin-Infused for a Taste of Luxury

2

Vadasz

Fresh Garlic and Dill Pickles

Vadasz Fresh Garlic and Dill Pickles 1

Gorgeously Gourmet Garlic and Dill Ribbons

3

Maille

French Extra Fine Cornichons Pack of 2

Maille French Extra Fine Cornichons  1

Fine, French-Style Cornichons for Meat and Cheese

4

Waitrose

Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins

Waitrose Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins 1

Popular Cocktail Gherkins With Lots of Bite

5

Mrs Elswood

Sweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices

Mrs Elswood Sweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices 1

Just Right for Packed Lunches

6

Psycho Pickles

Ghost Pepper Pickled Gherkins Pack of 2

Psycho Pickles Ghost Pepper Pickled Gherkins  1

Insanely Good Pickles With an Added Chilli Kick

7

Edmond Fallot

Extra Fine Gherkins

Edmond Fallot Extra Fine Gherkins 1

Top-Quality, Elegantly Flavoured Cornichons

8

Asda

Tangy and Crunchy Sliced Pickled Gherkins

Asda Tangy and Crunchy Sliced Pickled Gherkins 1

Strong Flavoured Slices With Proper Crunch

9

Dawtona

Swedish Style Salad

Dawtona Swedish Style Salad 1

Simple Scandi Salad Gherkins

10

Heinz

Hamburger Dill Chips

Heinz Hamburger Dill Chips 1

Your Burger Isn't Complete Without Them!

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

Garner's
Gin Pickled Gherkins

 Gin Pickled Gherkins 1
Source:waitrose.com
Reference price
£2.00
Mid
Reference price
£2.00
Mid

Lusciously Gin-Infused for a Taste of Luxury

Now we're getting fancy! In at number one are these lush, luxury gherkins pickled in fruity white wine and fragrant gin. Waitrose do tend to stock the finer end of the grocery selection and this jar certainly ticks that box. Garner's offer a delightful range of pickles using fresh, carefully selected ingredients every time so you can snack happy and healthy.


As well as the wine and gin combo, these gherkins are also flavoured with fragrant, heady dill and bitter fennel, which contrasts like a dream against the sweetness and crunch of the cucumber itself. This large jar is worth the price tag and could serve as a thoughtful gift for the gin-loving gourmand in your life! Top pick for salads, snacks, picnics or fancy spreads.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

Vadasz
Fresh Garlic and Dill Pickles

Reference price
£4.00
Mid

Gorgeously Gourmet Garlic and Dill Ribbons

Though they're labelled as pickles, these cucumber slices jarred in spirit vinegar are just the same as a good old gherkin. Where they do differ is the texture; they're sliced into silky ribbons. On top of that, the complex flavour blend is rich and nuanced, which we know you'll love.


The inclusion of dill, fennel, black peppercorns, caraway seeds, coriander and the slightly unusual addition of bitter turmeric turns these humble cucumbers into a real flavour sensation. It's no wonder they've won a Great Taste award! No salad is complete without a lip-smacking spoonful of these cold-brined bites.

No.3

Maille
French Extra Fine Cornichons Pack of 2

French Extra Fine Cornichons  1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£14.95
High
Reference price
£14.95
High

Fine, French-Style Cornichons for Meat and Cheese

Maille is known for its quality mustards and gorgeous, flavourful condiments, produced in the traditional French style since the 1700s. These 'extra fine' cornichons could be served up to Rick Stein by an elderly farmer's wife in the South of France and no one would bat an eyelid. They are firm to the bite, tangy and sweet; a beautiful contrast to cheese or meat.


They're pickled in spirit vinegar with the tasty addition of onions, mustard, spices and coriander and come as a twin pack, meaning you can power through the first jar with gusto and still have some in reserve! Just right for buffets or a picnic spread, these crunchy, sharp cornichons are truly delicious.

No.4

Waitrose
Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins

Crisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins 1
Source:waitrose.com
Reference price
£1.20
Low Mid
Reference price
£1.20
Low Mid

Popular Cocktail Gherkins With Lots of Bite

As usual, Waitrose's own brand cocktail gherkins are a cut above average, with a reasonable price tag. These ones are on the small size, just right for an amuse-bouche to satisfy guests before a fancy three-course feast or to take along to a posh picnic with some open-air opera (we can dream, can't we!?).


The barley malt vinegar used is a little more palatable than spirit vinegar; its citrus sweetness has a dark, warm aftertaste that feels elegant and sumptuous. The unspecified 'natural flavours' on the ingredients list keep it outside our top three, but the hearty customer reviews suggest this is a tried, tested and beloved product!

No.5

Mrs Elswood
Sweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices

Reference price
£1.80
Low Mid

Just Right for Packed Lunches

Friendly Mrs Elwood is the fairy godmother of packed lunch preparation. Simply pickled in spirit vinegar to preserve the juicy sweetness of the cucumber, these wide, fine slices are ideal for sandwiches that pack a flavour punch. They're readily available from all your favourite food shops from Tesco to Asda and Amazon Fresh. 


The sheer volume of this jar for the price is pretty appealing, and we like the subtle scattering of mustard seeds which take the flavour to pleasant new heights. Pop them into salads, layer them on top of burgers or include them in picnic platters with other savoury munchies.

No.6

Psycho Pickles
Ghost Pepper Pickled Gherkins Pack of 2

Ghost Pepper Pickled Gherkins  1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£11.95
High Mid
Reference price
£11.95
High Mid

Insanely Good Pickles With an Added Chilli Kick

Now for something you won't find on UK supermarket shelves. This bonkers range of gherkins and other pickled treats, jarred in Alabama USA, is as quirky in taste as its packaging suggests. We've selected this batch; a double whammy of nobbly cornichons with fiery ghost peppers


Even for the two-jar deal, the price is fairly high, so these nibbles might be best saved as a present or treat around summertime or the festive period – they'll liven up a Boxing Day buffet just as well as a sun-soaked picnic with cold cuts and cheese. The flavour is wonderfully wild without being overwhelming; just right for heat lovers who adore that cornichon crunch.

No.7

Edmond Fallot
Extra Fine Gherkins

Extra Fine Gherkins 1
Source:waitrose.com
Reference price
£3.55
Mid
Reference price
£3.55
Mid

Top-Quality, Elegantly Flavoured Cornichons

Ooh la la! Need some sweet little cornichons to add some pizzazz to a cheese board? These could be your classiest pick. For cornichons they're fairly large, sitting superbly on a cracker with pastrami or Stilton, but what we particularly love about these majestic mini cucumbers is the flavour combination. 


They're pickled in the usual spirit vinegar, but this is perked up with the addition of onion and yellow mustard seeds, plus a sprinkling of the more unusual blend of tarragon and coriander seeds, taking these little mouthfuls to a moreish new level. Worth the cost if you can afford it! 

No.8

Asda
Tangy and Crunchy Sliced Pickled Gherkins

Reference price
£1.20
Low Mid
Reference price
£1.20
Low Mid

Strong Flavoured Slices With Proper Crunch

One of the top perks of this sizable jar of gherkins has to be the price tag; it's a bargain for nearly 500 grams of lunch-enhancing flavour. We also love the length and width of these tasty slices; they'd be ideal for a chunky sandwich on spongy sourdough or crowning a colossal burger patty.


They are pickled in standard spirit vinegar, but the addition of dill, as well as mustard seeds, gives a pleasing complexity which is impressive for affordable, own-brand gherkins like these. A fair few positive reviews on the Asda website call these 'perfect' for snacking and sarnies. 

No.9

Dawtona
Swedish Style Salad

Swedish Style Salad 1
Source:tesco.com
Reference price
£1.29
Low Mid
Reference price
£1.29
Low Mid

Simple Scandi Salad Gherkins

We think you'll enjoy these round slices of cucumber, pickled in spirit vinegar and flavoured with mustard seeds, based on their crunchy texture, zingy taste and the fact that they are from Polish pickle experts Dawtona. 


The price for the quantity isn't especially eye-catching when compared with other products, but the sprinkling of mustard seeds adds a warm nuance to the flavour which will appeal to those who enjoy a simple, classic gherkin in their salad. The pieces are flat rather than crinkled, adding bite rather than sweetness to any snack.

No.10

Heinz
Hamburger Dill Chips

Hamburger Dill Chips 1
Source:amazon.co.uk
Reference price
£5.90
High Mid
Reference price
£5.90
High Mid

Your Burger Isn't Complete Without Them!

If, on your hunt for the perfect gherkin, you're visualising a classic fifties diner with rollerskating waiters and milkshakes as big as your head, look no further than this hefty jar of crinkle-cut gherkin rounds which will turn any burger, meaty or otherwise, into retro snack heaven!


We love the idea of the 'tart dill taste' on the label, though the 'natural flavours' on the ingredients list mean the blend may be less complex than gherkins using fresh dill. These zig-zag cut cucumber pieces are also pickled in white vinegar, the sharpest and strongest vinegar option, which won't appeal to everyone.

Summary

Now that you've read our handy buying guide, shopping for gherkins should no longer leave you in a pickle! We think we've selected ten really moreish options you can slap into a sandwich, use to garnish a burger or nibble as an amuse-bouche along with cold meats, olives or cheese.


Author: Annie Hopkins

Top 5 Gherkins

No. 1: Garner's Gin Pickled Gherkins

No. 2: VadaszFresh Garlic and Dill Pickles

No. 3: MailleFrench Extra Fine Cornichons Pack of 2

No. 4: WaitroseCrisp and Sweet Cocktail Gherkins

No. 5: Mrs ElswoodSweet Cucumber Sandwich Slices

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.

Most Viewed
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Veggie Mince

6 Best

New Arrivals
Featured Rankings Similar to Food cupboard

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.