A good skincare routine is vital to keep oily skin under control. Of course, removing your makeup and cleansing are obvious steps to stave off the shine, but toning is easily forgotten. Toner is the crucial step that helps rebalance the skin's pH and prepares it for any further treatments, and can completely change the game for those with oily skin in both the short and long term.
Whether you're after a facial toner for sensitive, acne-prone skin or skin with large pores, an alcohol-free or cruelty-free product, we've broken down the steps to follow in finding your perfect pick. We'll also share our top 10 products available from Amazon, John Lewis and Boots. Moreover, we have partnered with Makeup Artist Claire Higgins for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver you the best information.
Quick List - Top Toners for Oily Skin
Garnier Organic
An Ethical Yet Affordable Drugstore Toner to Purify and Mattify
A qualified Beauty Therapist and Makeup Artist. I provide professional makeup services for all occasions, whether it be for a bride on their wedding day or backstage at a photo shoot. I also enjoy teaching through hosting live talks on my social media, masterclass events, and 1-1 training. My favourite style of makeup is most definitely vibrant. I love a colourful eyeshadow palette... or 10!
A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
Claire is a qualified Beauty Therapist and Makeup Artist; she provides professional makeup services for all occasions from bridal to backstage at photo shoots. Claire also teaches masterclass events as well as 1-1 training, and when she gets the chance, enjoys sharing her expertise hosting live talks on her social media. She's a big fan of the vibrant style and loves a colourful palette... or 10!
Keep up-to-date with Claire through her Facebook and Instagram page where you can learn the latest tips and tricks when it comes to makeup application and also get inspired to try new looks!
To specify, we are focusing on alcohols like ethanol, methanol, isopropyl or ethyl. Alcohol was once a very popular ingredient in skincare targeted for oily skin, as it has antiseptic properties that kill bacteria, and it can often feel very comfortable on oily skin as it dries quickly meaning that you don't feel like there is any leftover product on your face.
Precisely the reason that it can feel so instantly comfortable is that it can contribute to the breaking down of the skin's natural barrier, which can conversely cause it to make your skin more susceptible to bacteria or other outside aggressors. Moreover, alcohol can cause the skin to dry out a little bit too much. When the skin becomes very dehydrated, it can then be encouraged to produce more oil leading you into another cycle of oily skin!
Want to tackle dry skin? Why not check out our guide on the best moisturisers!
Oily skin tends to be more resilient than dry skin, and sometimes it can handle these ingredients, and even benefit from their presence in small amounts. However, we strongly advise being careful when using a product with a high alcohol concentration or even consider going alcohol-free.
The active ingredients in your skincare are the ingredients that deliver the product's desired effects. For a toner, your active ingredients will be the ones working to rebalance the oil levels in your skin! Active ingredients we recommend looking for fall under the category of Alpha Hydroxy Acids, or AHAs.
These are acids derived from foods whose main benefit is to improve skin cell turnover rate – that is, the rate at which your skin renews. This is important as it stops your pores from getting clogged, improves the absorbency and effectiveness of your skincare, and clears away excess oil from the skin.
Specific AHAs we advise that you look out for are glycolic, citric, salicylic, and lactic acids. You will find that they help to remove dead skin cells and excess oil from the face, improving your complexion and tackling acne, too.
One of the most frustrating results of having oily skin is that it can result in more frequent acne breakouts, which can lead to scars or discolouration.
If you have experiences with the after-effects of acne breakouts, we advise looking for a toner that includes ingredients like niacinamide and vitamin C. These both help to correct hyperpigmentation, which is what causes those scars and discoloured patches to be so visible!
If you are looking for ways to cover hyperpigmentation, check out our guides on the best bb creams and the best face powders!
Although some toners will be marketed as specifically for oily skin, we also advise keeping an eye out for properties such as 'balancing', 'clarifying', 'purifying', and 'refining'. Oily skin is caused by irregularity in sebum production, so ultimately you are looking to regulate it again, and these terms let you know that they'll help with that.
If you have super oily skin, we also recommend looking for toners that promise to be 'mattifying' and 'astringent'. Although these may not be suitable in the long-term (they can eventually dry out the skin for some people), on a short term basis they can really help reduce the appearance of shine by stripping your face of excess oils.
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Clarins Purifying Toning Lotion | ![]() | An Aquatic Plant Formula for Healthy, Bright and Shine-Free Skin | |
2 | Aesop B & Tea Balancing Toner | ![]() | Rebalance Your Skin Gently With Added Provitamin B5 | |
3 | Garnier Organic Thyme Perfecting Toner | ![]() | An Ethical Yet Affordable Drugstore Toner to Purify and Mattify | |
4 | Kiehl's Calendula Herbal Extract Alcohol-Free Toner | ![]() | Soothe Your Skin With 100% Natural Ingredients | |
5 | Elemis Balancing Lavender Toner | ![]() | A Great Choice for Balancing Out Oily and Combination Skin | |
6 | COSRX AHA/BA Clarifying Treatment Toner | ![]() | A Korean AHA Toner That's Gentle Enough for Everyday Use | |
7 | Caudalie Vinopure Clear Skin Purifying Toner | ![]() | With Natural Salicylic Acid to Tighten Large Pores and Smooth Uneveness | |
8 | La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Lotion | ![]() | An Astringent, Dermatologist-Tested Toner for Sensitive Skin | |
9 | Murad Essential-C Toner | ![]() | Rich in Vitamin C and E to Reduce the Effects of Acne Scarring | |
10 | Kiehl's Blue Astringent Herbal Lotion | ![]() | A Cornerstone Toner and Treatment for Combating Oily Skin and Imperfections |
Our winning product is Clarins' Purifying Toning Lotion, which is targeted to both combination and oily skin. An alcohol-free toner, it is enriched with meadowsweet and witch hazel which help to reduce shine and brighten your complexion.
This fantastic toning lotion will help to normalise the excess surface oils found on the skin, and to restore it to a natural balance without dehydrating. It will also help to minimise the appearance of larger pores, and leave your skin feeling clean and refreshed.
This Aesop toner is a gentle, alcohol-free blend that contains fortifying anti-oxidants to refine pores and to help balance oil levels on the skin's surface for a fresh and clean feel.
We recommend this if you are looking to tone your skin and keep its oil production under control without drying your skin too much. It is also enhanced with provitamin B5, in the form of panthenol and antioxidant green tea, which will keep your skin beautifully moisturised and soft.
This Garnier Organic Thyme Purifying and Perfecting Toner is our least expensive choice for an effective toner for combination to oily skin. It doesn't scrimp on its ingredients: it includes salicylic acid to help purify your skin. We would simply advise being careful with it if you have sensitive skin, as it does have relatively high alcohol content.
If you are also concerned about the ethical stance of your products, this may be the perfect choice for you. Not only are its key ingredients organically and ethically sourced, but the bottle also contains 100% recycled plastic and is in turn recyclable.
Specifically designed to soothe problem skin, and perfect for normal to oily skin types, it will help rebalance the oil on the skin's surface while maintaining and restoring integrity to the skin's appearance.
A gentle and calming lotion for combination to oily skin, this is a purifying treatment that will rebalance the skin's pH level with the help of extracts of lavender, quillaja wood and sweet betty flower.
This toner will also help to soften the skin as well as clarifying and rebalancing oil secretion. Moreover, it is alcohol- and detergent- free so you do not have to worry about it being too harsh on the skin when you're working to purify it in preparation for your skincare routine!
This AHA/BHA toner from one of the most loved K-Beauty brands, COSRX, is ideal for those who are looking a multi-use daily toner. Gentle yet effective, this product works to soothe and soften the skin. Additionally, it helps to eliminate impurities and properly hydrate.
Given that it is made with natural ingredients such as pyrus malus (apple) fruit water, and salix alba (willow) bark water, this toner is suitable for all skin types. Being easy to apply, this is a great choice for those who are looking something simple and natural.
Caudalie's Vinopure toner is enriched with natural salicylic acid, which is a gentle exfoliator that will help to unclog and tighten pores. At the same time, the Vinopure Clarifying toner has grape-seed polyphenols, which will help to repair and rejuvenate the skin's appearance.
A highly natural formula, it is specifically designed to refine naturally blemish-prone or oily skin for a fresh and soft feeling. We particularly recommend this toner to people who are concerned about skin unevenness caused by excess oil production.
This astringent toner is specifically formulated for sensitive, oily, spot-prone skin. It contains lipo-hydroxy acid (LHA) which is a micro-exfoliant, to completely unblock pores to help them appear smaller and clear the skin's surface of impurities.
Although it is a strong toner in terms of function, it has been formulated and dermatologically tested to be gentle on sensitive skin. It also contains no colourants and no lanolin; however, we would caution for super-sensitive skin that there is a slight presence of fragrance in the ingredients listing.
One of the most frustrating experiences of dealing with oily skin is that it can be more prone to acne and imperfections. This toner is a perfect choice for those who have balanced their skin's oil production but are still left with scarring.
We recommend using it at night, to help refresh the skin and restore it to its natural pH levels. It contains orange fruit extract and vitamins C and E to help renew the skin, whilst the rice extract enhances the skin's ability to retain moisture. A wonderful choice for creating smooth, flawless skin, you may want to use this after getting your oil levels under control.
The Kiehl's Blue Astringent Herbal Lotion was formulated in 1964 and it has remained on the market since because of its powerful soothing and balancing properties. Thanks to the menthol extract, it will work to redress the balance of oil production in your skin.
Specifically targeted for very oily skin, it can be used in three different ways: as an all-over toner after cleansing, as a spot treatment for problem areas, or as an aftershave for men. We advise that you only use this product if you definitely have oily skin, as it can be a little abrasive for more sensitive or combination skin types.
The skin's sebaceous glands, found under the skin's surface, naturally produce sebum, which is an oily substance made of fats. The production of sebum is healthy, as it helps to protect the skin from infection, and keeps the skin from drying out by moisturising it.
However, oily skin can occur when the sebaceous glands produce excess oil, resulting in a "shiny" or "greasy" appearance of the skin. In addition to this, oily skin can be more prone to clogged pores, which can result in breakouts and the pores appearing larger, all of which can lead to imperfections in the skin's surface.
Toners can help to clean and reduce the appearance of the pores, while also tightening the cell gaps after cleansing, as well as balancing oil production. Your skin should generally be at a pH level of 5.5, which is slightly acidic. Oily skin tends to be a higher pH, so finding a toner that is going to restore your skin's natural pH level is important.
Written and researched by Hannah Kato
No. 1: Clarins |Purifying Toning Lotion
No. 2: Aesop|B & Tea Balancing Toner
No. 3: Garnier Organic|Thyme Perfecting Toner
No. 4: Kiehl's|Calendula Herbal Extract Alcohol-Free Toner
No. 5: Elemis|Balancing Lavender Toner
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Automotive
Baby Products
Beauty
Books
Business, Industry & Science
Computers & Accessories
DIY, Garden & Tools
Electronics & Photo
Fashion
Grocery
Health & Personal Care
Home & Kitchen
Large Appliances
Musical Instruments & DJ
PC & Video Games
Pet Supplies
Sports & Outdoors
Stationery & Office Products
Toys & Games